Dear friends,<\/p>\n
The time has come that we set our work straight in language. The People\u2019s Republic of China is a totalitarian state. Of its own kind, to be sure, hence neo-totalitarian, but totalitarian it is. No clarity of analysis is possible without clarity of language. The PRC is not \u201can authoritarian system,\u201d it is \u201ca totalitarian state.\u201d<\/p>\n
The final straw has been the imposition of outright tyranny in Xinjiang<\/a>, with extremes of surveillance, heavily intrusive thought-work, and mass detentions in \u201cre-education\u201d facilities. But also the relentless tightening of dictatorship during Xi Jinping\u2019s reign, culminating in the decimation of the community of human rights lawyers<\/a> that has stood as a bastion of courage and civility.<\/p>\n The characteristics of totalitarianism<\/a> are<\/p>\n The proof of terror is now in Xinjiang. Where the regime sees it to be necessary, its footprint is tyranny. The state is deep into the regulation of private lives, now intensified in the \u201csocial credit system<\/a>\u201d by which rewards and punishments are distributed in the population according to patterns of private behaviour. There has never been bureaucracy like the PRC bureaucracies. Xi has cast off pragmatism and clad his reign in the omnipresent China Dream<\/a> ideology of nationalism and chauvinism.<\/p>\n The result of totalitarian patterns of state rule is that social life is atomised and community crushed. Many Chinese can now live their daily lives much as they want, and in comfort. But there is no freedom of assembly, association, information or deliberation.<\/p>\n I know that there is honest reluctance in our own community to adopting the language of totalitarianism. There has been hope and expectation of opening up. But in political life and civil society it is not happening. Far from it, the direction of travel is to shutting down. We should now recognise this in the language we use.<\/p>\n Yours respectfully,<\/p>\n Stein Ringen, Professor of Political Economy, King\u2019s College London<\/p>\n <\/p>\n\n